Welcome to Old Stove Pub, a hidden gem nestled along the scenic Montauk Highway in Sagaponack, NY. If you’ve ever driven past and wondered whether to step inside, let me assure you, it’s time to take the plunge. This inviting establishment boasts not only a charming ambiance but also an impressive menu that could easily reinvigorate your dining experience.

One of the most noteworthy aspects of Old Stove Pub is its incredible commitment to quality. Reviewers rave about their delicious offerings, including a delightful tartare trio, delectable stuffed eggplant, and a crab cake that has quickly gained a reputation of its own. The restaurant excels in balancing superior taste with a thoughtful presentation that showcases the skill and creativity of the culinary team.

Old Stove Pub doesn’t just stop at great food; the cocktail menu is equally impressive. Imagine savoring an exquisite Espresso Martini while enjoying the sunset, surrounded by a lovely outdoor setting that enhances the overall dining experience. Though the prices might be on the higher side—like $22 for a cocktail—many find it worth every cent, especially given the memorable flavors that keep you coming back for more.

The service here has been described as attentive and warm, with the owner often on-site to ensure every detail is perfect. Customers highlight the welcoming vibe that fosters new friendships, as exemplified by one couple who found themselves sharing a table with strangers who soon became friends.

As you sip your wine and nibble on light snacks or indulge in a home-cooked dessert like baklava, you’ll find yourself lulled into conversation—not just with your dining companions but with the atmosphere itself. With live music that perfectly complements the ambiance without overpowering it, Old Stove Pub sets the stage for a truly delightful night out.

Located at 3516 Montauk Hwy, this pub is not just another dining spot; it’s an experience waiting to be explored. Be sure to call ahead at +1 631-537-3300 to reserve your table, and join the many who have fallen in love with this wonderful establishment. I can’t wait for them to expand their reach to New York City—until then, the Old Stove Pub is a treasure you absolutely must discover.